Toilet Handle Broke: What Now? How To Fix It?

June Steele in How To

1/28/24

[updated: 2/29/24]

This article may contain affiliate links, learn more.

You might be thinking my toilet handle broke, what now? Do I call a plumber, or is this something that I might be able to handle myself? In this comprehensive guide, we will walk you through the process of replacing a broken toilet handle, offering detailed steps and valuable insights. Dealing with a broken toilet handle can be a hassle, but with the right approach, tools, and knowledge, you can successfully address the issue and restore your toilet’s functionality.

Understanding the Causes of Toilet Handle Breakage

Toilet handles can break due to various factors, including wear and tear, corrosion, physical damage, or improper use. Recognizing the underlying reasons for the handle breakage can help you take preventive measures to avoid future occurrences, ensuring long-term functionality.

Gathering the Essential Tools and Materials

Before commencing the replacement, it’s crucial to gather all the necessary tools and materials, including a new toilet handle, specific parts for your toilet model, adjustable wrench, and pliers. Having everything prepared in advance will streamline the replacement process.

Turning Off the Water Supply to the Toilet

Prior to beginning any work, it’s essential to shut off the water supply to the toilet to prevent potential leaks. Locate and turn the shut-off valve near the toilet’s base in a clockwise direction to stop the water flow.

Removing the Broken Handle with Care

Lift the toilet bowl lid to access the rear of the toilet handle. Using an adjustable wrench or your hands, carefully remove the plastic nut that is securing the broken handle in place, followed by detaching the handle from the toilet. Take care to keep track of the plastic nut and small parts to avoid misplacement.

Selecting a Replacement Handle Suited to Your Toilet

When choosing a replacement handle, consider factors like design, material, and compatibility with your toilet model. Opt for a handle that complements your bathroom aesthetics and aligns with your toilet’s flushing mechanism.

Installing the New Handle Securely

Attach the new handle to the toilet, ensuring a secure fit. Use the plastic nut and provided hardware to fasten the handle and test its functionality by flushing the toilet.

Adjusting the Chain Length for Optimal Operation

In certain instances, you may need to adjust the length of the chain or plastic chain connecting the handle to the flapper inside the toilet tank to ensure smooth and effective operation of the flushing mechanism.

Inside of a toilet bowl plunger with plastic chain.

Testing and Fine-Tuning for Optimum Performance

Following the installation of the new handle, test the toilet to ensure proper flushing and smooth handle operation. Make any necessary adjustments to optimize its performance.

Implementing Preventative Maintenance Measures

To minimize the risk of future handle breakages, consider regular maintenance practices such as cleaning and lubricating the handle and its components. Additionally, be mindful of the force applied when flushing the toilet to prevent unnecessary wear and damage.